9/2011 This one is losing its charm more and more with each re-read. This time through, my 4th, will be the last, I think. The seams show now that I have a good grasp of the plot. The writing is immediate, romantic, and not very good. There are characters, most notably Jenny, that I like a lot. But overall? Not loving it.12/2009 I didn't love it as much on the re-read as I did the first time around. There were some plot holes that were more apparent this time, and some niggling annoyances. It's certainly absorbing and affecting. And who doesn't love the braw Jamie or his sister Jenny. I adore Jenny.